As Taiwan's Election Race Heats Up, China Weighs On Voters' Minds

Dec 1, 2019
Originally published on December 2, 2019 10:38 am

At a recent election campaign event in Taiwan, a procession of women beat ceremonial drums, dance and wave lotus-shaped umbrellas in celebration. But beyond the slogans promising national security and prosperity, the topic on everyone's mind is what to do about China.

The star of the event is Han Kuo-yu, a pro-Beijing candidate running for president with the opposition Kuomintang, who poses a stark contrast with the current leaders.

"[The governing party] relentlessly uses Taiwan independence as a way to negate China," Han, the mayor of the city of Kaohsiung, said to rallygoers at the event in Miaoli county, just south of Taiwan's capital of Taipei. "However, Taiwan and Beijing are one family."

Taiwan, a U.S. ally, has its own government, military and capitalist economy, but the Chinese Communist Party says Taiwan belongs to the People's Republic of China.

Voters are preparing to elect Taiwan's next president and legislature on Jan. 11. While the leading opposition candidate sympathizes with Beijing, President Tsai Ing-wen's Democratic Progressive Party calls China the "enemy of democracy."

Many Taiwanese are also closely watching what is happening in Hong Kong, where more than five months of sometimes violent protests are pushing back against mainland China's control. Taiwan largely wants to avoid becoming another Hong Kong, which could tip the election in favor of President Tsai, who is running for reelection and has a widening lead in opinion polls.

Taiwan's President Tsai Ing-wen delivers a speech in Taipei on Nov. 17 as she launches her reelection campaign. Taiwan will hold its presidential election on Jan. 11.
Chiang Ying-ying / AP

"We see the freedom enjoyed by the Hong Kong people is being chipped away," Joseph Wu, Taiwan's foreign minister, told NPR. "We see the experience of Hong Kong is not quite what the Chinese government promised in the early days."

"One country" rejected

Still, China's leader Xi Jinping has been pressuring Taiwan to follow Hong Kong's model.

It's called "one country, two systems," meaning Hong Kong is part of China but keeps some autonomy, including government functions and independent courts — in theory.

Many Hong Kongers accuse the leadership in Hong Kong and Beijing of eroding their limited autonomy. That sentiment is in part why thousands have taken to the street in anti-government protests that are now in their sixth month.

Taiwan's leaders flatly reject any proposal for Taiwan to enter a similar arrangement with China.

"Hong Kong is on the verge of chaos due to the failure of 'one country, two systems,' " President Tsai said on Taiwan's National Day in October. "The overwhelming consensus among Taiwan's 23 million people is our rejection of 'one country, two systems,' regardless of party affiliation or political position."

Supporters of President Tsai cheer at her reelection campaign launch in November.
Chiang Ying-ying / AP

More than 86% say they would prefer to maintain Taiwan's current status, according to the latest polls.

Even the opposition candidate Han, who has sparked controversy over his pro-Beijing stance, disavowed the Hong Kong policy after the protests erupted. "Taiwanese people can never accept ['one country, two systems'], unless it's over my dead body," he said.

Taiwan has been preparing for China to attack ever since Nationalist leader Chiang Kai-shek retreated to the island in 1949, along with 2 million of his supporters and soldiers, after losing a civil war against Mao Zedong's Communist forces.

Xi has said Taiwan should unify with mainland China peacefully but has threatened to use force to do so.

As Beijing steps up militaristic rhetoric, the U.S. has stepped up its support f0r the island. It has bulked up its de facto embassy in Taipei and passed legislation encouraging official travel between the U.S. and Taiwan. This year, the U.S. made a high-profile $8 billion sale of fighter jets and other military equipment to the island, angering Beijing.

Taiwan considers itself a bulwark of democracy in the Asia-Pacific region, where China is increasingly asserting its power.

Supporters of Kuomingtang presidential candidate Han Kuo-yu wave the flag of Taiwan. Many in the party favor closer ties with Beijing, although it is a minority view in Taiwan.
Emily Feng / NPR

"We are on the front lines. We have faced all these threats and Chinese infiltration for decades," says Freddy Lim, a death metal rocker turned co-founder of one of Taiwan's most liberal political organizations, the New Power Party.

The nearly five-year-old party is now going through an existential crisis over whether to support Tsai's reelection bid. In August, Lim quit the party to run for reelection to his legislative seat as an independent so he could back President Tsai, arguing the stakes of losing the presidency to a pro-Beijing candidate are too high.

Better collaboration with China

Central to every election in Taiwan is the question: Does Taiwan, a small island, sidle up to its much bigger neighbor China to develop its economy, or keep it at arm's length?

"There is no such thing as economic and trade without politics in Taiwan," says Lev Nachman, a doctoral candidate researching Taiwanese political movements.

Some politicians have tried to stake out some middle ground, such as the upstart Taiwan People's Party that formed in August. It has come under criticism for seemingly waffling on its stance toward Beijing.

"We try to enhance the collaboration with the people with the civil society of mainland China, especially in terms of economics and culture. We very much support the kind of nongovernmental interaction," explains Kimyung Keng, one of the Taiwan People's Party candidates running for a district legislative seat.

Unify one way or another

Despite its small size and dwindling number of international allies, Taiwan has managed to nurture a robust economy. Homegrown corporate champions include electronics-making giant Foxconn and the Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. Wages are rising and the unemployment rate is just under 3.8%, one of the lowest levels in two decades. President Tsai has built up economic ties with Southeast Asia to diversify Taiwan's trade portfolio away from mainland China.

But supporters of opposition candidate Han say the president has made a mistake in shutting out Beijing. Taiwan should not be afraid of unification with China, rallygoers at the recent campaign event told NPR.

Chang An-lo speaks with foreign media in Taipei in 2014. After serving 10 years in a U.S. federal prison on drug trafficking charges, Chang returned to Taiwan in 2013 to pursue political ambitions as the leader of the China Unification Promotion Party.
Wally Santana / AP

The staunchest of the pro-China camp is a prominent gangster turned politician. Chang An-lo once helped lead one of Taiwan's biggest gangs, the Bamboo Union. Now, he heads the Chinese Unification Promotion Party, which nominates no candidates of its own but backs every pro-Beijing Kuomintang candidate.

"When China unifies Taiwan either violently or peacefully, do you want military rule or one country, two systems? The latter is still the best way for Taiwan," Chang says. "How could an economy of 1.4 billion people be bad for Taiwan? And what's wrong with returning to China, as we are all Chinese?"

Taiwanese mostly disagree. The latest polls on identity show the island's residents feel increasingly Taiwanese, not Chinese.

"There is a huge generational difference," says Luo Chi-cheng, a Democratic Progressive lawmaker running for reelection. "Young people pay close attention to what happens in Hong Kong because [otherwise] in the future, Taiwan may be forced to accept the so-called one country, two system model."

Older voters tend to care more about economic development, according to Luo. It is the younger Taiwanese, he notes, who have longer to live and more opportunities to decide future election outcomes.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

LULU GARCIA-NAVARRO, HOST:

Protesters in Hong Kong have been out on the streets for six months now. And close by, Taiwan is watching carefully. It's election season there. They go to the polls on January 11 to elect their president and legislature. NPR's Beijing correspondent Emily Feng went to the Taiwanese capital, Taipei, to explore the long shadow Hong Kong's turmoil has cast.

(SOUNDBITE OF PROTEST AMBIENCE)

EMILY FENG, BYLINE: This is a presidential campaign rally, Taiwan-style. A procession of rallygoers beat drums and wave umbrellas shaped like lotuses.

(SOUNDBITE OF PROTEST AMBIENCE)

FENG: The guest of honor today at this Hakka temple is Han Kuo-yu, the presidential nominee for the Kuomintang, or the KMT Party. It historically leans pro-Beijing. And the topic on everyone's mind - what to do about China. Han Kuo-yu gives a speech promising to keep Taiwan safe, in part by not provoking Beijing.

HAN KUO-YU: (Through interpreter) My opponents relentlessly use Taiwan independence as a way to negate China, but Taiwan and Beijing are one family.

FENG: Taiwan considers itself independent of Beijing, a position Beijing vehemently rejects. Han is controversial for welcoming closer ties with Beijing. Many KMT supporters have family who were born in mainland China and then fled to Taiwan when the KMT lost to the Chinese Communist Party in 1949.

Even now, rallygoers like this one welcome Chinese rule. He only gave his last name, He, because of the political sensitivity around this year's elections.

HE: (Through interpreter) If Taiwan has a prosperous economy, mainland China won't dare to interfere with Taiwan. I'm not afraid of unification with China. If it lets the people live safely and happily, what's wrong with unification?

FENG: But the party in power now, the independence-leading Democratic Progressive Party, or DPP, warns Beijing is acting on false pretenses. Beijing hopes one day to unify Taiwan, perhaps even through military invasion. And one possible way Beijing could govern Taiwan is how it currently rules Hong Kong. There's something called the one country, two systems model. It's where Hong Kong is a part of China but is supposed to enjoy some political autonomy until 2047.

FREDDY LIM: Hong Kong issue shows to Taiwanese people that - what one country, two system is about.

FENG: Freddy Lim is a death-metal rocker turned co-founder of one of Taiwan's most liberal political parties, the activist New Power Party. He sees the erosion of civil liberties under Chinese rule in Hong Kong as a harbinger for what Taiwan could become if it does not resist Chinese Communist Party influence.

LIM: Not just because that - we are very close to Hong Kong - we have so many Hong Kong friends, and we feel so close to what's happened there. But also, we can feel the reflection on our own situation.

FENG: But being a democracy, Taiwan has many dissenting voices.

CHANG AN-LO: (Through interpreter) When China unifies Taiwan, either violently or peacefully, do you want military rule or one country, two systems? One country, two systems is still best for Taiwan.

FENG: This is Chang An-lo. A former mob boss turned politician, he is at the far end of the spectrum, advocating Taiwan's complete unification with mainland China. He once helped lead one of Taiwan's biggest gangs, the Bamboo Union. Now he heads a party which nominates no candidates of its own but backs every pro-Beijing KMT candidate that runs.

CHANG: (Through interpreter) How could an economy of 1.4 billion people be bad for Taiwan? And what's wrong with returning to China, as we are all Chinese?

FENG: But the latest polling data tells otherwise. It shows the island's residents feel increasingly Taiwanese, not Chinese. Only about 10% are in favor of unification with mainland China at some point.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: (Non-English language spoken).

FENG: A speaker blares campaign slogans for this majority-party candidate.

CHI-CHENG LUO: My name's Chi-cheng Luo.

FENG: Luo is a legislator running for reelection, and he thinks Taiwanese voters will continue to become more distant from Beijing.

LUO: Young people do pay a lot of attention to what happens in Hong Kong because in the future, the so-called one country, two system model can be forced to be accepted by Taiwan.

FENG: Young Taiwanese voters are more invested in Hong Kong and Taiwanese democracy because they feel their future depends on it, says Luo. And young people, he notes, have a longer time to live, and thus more opportunities to vote.

Emily Feng, NPR News, Taipei, Taiwan. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.